Chris,
You said C&C welcome, so hopefully it's not whether we like it or not, that is a personal thing; it is about the balance, the form and the finish.
The balance is right, Pete has already noted the inner shape to the outer curve, you've also made a good job of the wide rim to give it interest. The overall shape and finish fit's together well.
Yes some won't like it and admittedly its not something I'd think to turn but that does not detract from the good work you've done.