Les,
sorry to be so long commenting on this piece, truly I cannot make up my mind.
Everything about it is right but I can't get it to settle comfortably in my eye - and I don't know why.
The nearest I can get is the scale, I can't see how big it is and you don't say, so although it is a perfectly curved shape, with a sympathetic finish, it looks like it's no bigger than 4" diameter. Size is not an issue but at that size it looks to have a slightly heavy look to it.