Pete, I've had screws fail on me, only on my 1" long jaws though, I put it down to them being over stressed due to the length they had to hold against.
I now change my screws on a regular basis.
As I've posted before, if you buy 'branded' screws they are about £5 per 8, down at the local tools and fixings I can get a dozen for £2. That's a new set and spares in case I drop one in the shavings.